Sunday, January 29, 2012

Change


I think that a major theme throughout Ragtime is change. It appeared in each story within the novel and in some cases ended up bringing together some of the characters that in the beginning weren’t even acquaintances to start with. 

Fairly near the start, the New Rochelle family, especially Father, lives in their own world, of relaxation and comfort, a luxury that a larger part of the world doesn’t get to enjoy due to lack of wealth. Once Sarah and the baby turn up, they are forced to change, especially Mother. When Mother decides to take them in, I think she starts to feel like more of a mother-figure and that, in turn, makes her feel like a better person. Not only is this a change for the family, but it is also a change for Sarah. We don’t know her story, but because she ended up trying to bury her child, she must not have had a great background. Having a relatively good family take her in to their home and give her food to eat and a place to sleep was a definitely a change, but in a completely different way.

I think that Coalhouse, as well as Sarah, had a big impact on Younger Brother’s life. Before they came along, he seemed to be kind of a loner who never did or said anything. Once Coalhouse shows up in there house and, later on when Sarah dies trying to help him, Younger Brother has a life changing experience in which he wants to help them so much and is willing to do almost anything. This comes through especially in the scene where Father is reading about the exotic birds and Younger Brother runs out of the room feeling like he’s suffocating from the atmosphere in which he’s surrounded. So having them appear in his life definitely has a life changing impact on him. 

With Evelyn Nesbit, there was so much going on in her life, at times it was hard to keep straight what was going on with her and why she was even a crucial character to the novel. But one of her best acquaintances was with Tateh and his daughter. It was similar to Younger Brother’s connection to Coalhouse. Evelyn grew so attached to Tateh and the community that lived in the slums, that she almost wanted to be like them, dressing in rags and helping. But even though she was doing this, in a way it really didn’t make a difference in her life, because after seeing all of these terrible things in the poor part of the town, at the end of the day she could always go back to her cozy, happy life of luxury.

In some of these cases, there actually was a meaning and sometimes life altering change that took place, but in some, even though it may have seemed like the same amount of importance, it didn’t have as much of an impact as it maybe ought to have had.

Monday, January 23, 2012

Comparisons to Ragtime


Before I started reading Ragtime, I had had a pretty positive view of the Ragtime Era, from other books, movies, etc. However, since I ventured into this novel, my opinions about it have changed a lot.

One of the first visual interactions I had with that time period was watching “Meet Me in St. Louis” which takes place is 1903, towards the end of the Ragtime era. But the entire movie is just gives an image of how great the time was. The movie shows an ordinary family during this time and their struggles with each other and with society. While you’re watching the movie and getting into the story, these problems seem hard, but not once you put them in perspective.

Another story that is relevant to this time is Pollyanna, written by Eleanor H. Porter in 1913. It’s the story of a young girl whose parents have both died and she goes to live with her wealthy aunt, and just how they grow close and the adventures she goes on. There is a dramatic climax towards the end where she is injured and it ends with them traveling to the city for her to have a surgical operation, which once again, is terrible, but not in comparison.

In comparison to Ragtime, these both seem like stories with such an innocent tone and an unrealistic sense of the time period. Going into this novel, I was assuming it would be similar to the afore mentioned stories. However it gave a completely different image of the time: from the terror and violence due to racial segregation to the complicated love story of Colehouse and Sarah, the story was very different. I think that this is mostly due to the different point of view. The other two stories were from families higher up in the social class and a big part of Ragtime comes from black people, who in this scenario aren’t necessarily lower class, but they are definitely discriminated against and have an entirely different perspective due to this. 

Reading Ragtime definitely gave me a completely different idea of that time period and makes me wonder what other eras have not been done justice due to their portrayal shown through movies, books, etc.