Monday, May 14, 2012

Reflections on the class!!

I came into this class in January not exactly sure of what kind of awesomeness we would be delving into, but since I had been in Mr. Mitchell’s 20th Century Novel class the previous semester, there were no doubts that it would be very entertaining and enjoyable.

So, you know how there are those classes that you pretty much like, but either the books are lame or the conversation is boring? I can honestly say nothing of the sort about History as Fiction. I seriously have enjoyed every novel that we read this semester. We had our challenges, no doubt (cough, cough…Mumbo Jumbo), but even through those challenges, there was something enjoyable about them.

And if the novels were lacking interest at the moment, the in-class conversations always made it worthwhile. I’ll never forget our class discussion after our first Mumbo Jumbo assignment. There was a big mix of moans and straight out laughs at the craziness of the first chapter, but it was Mr. Mitchell’s enthusiasm that got us through it.

This class was not only fun, but it was actually really educational…as weird as that sounds. Libra was so cool, not only because I find the Kennedy assassination fascinating, but also because it made me start to think of the actual assassination, the time period, and the people involved (including Lee) very differently. Doing my panel presentation on it also helped to dig even deeper into some of the more hidden aspects of the novel.

All in all, this class was super fun and definitely the perfect class to end the year with!

Sunday, May 13, 2012

From Lee to Lee Harvey Oswald


     
In reading Libra, I became aware of the power that a book or movie has to make the audience feel sympathetic towards a person that we would normally only have negative feelings for. I know that several people in class, including myself, felt very differently about the Lee that we read about in the novel than about the Lee Harvey Oswald that is only known for murdering John F. Kennedy. Knowing the backstory of what seems to be a notorious killer, or really any negative figure, can completely change how people see them.

I think one example of this is definitely shown through the story of Bonnie and Clyde. These were people who stole and killed several people, but in the movie, you “live” with them and even if you don’t agree with what they do, you still start to get a better sense of why they became that way and why they’re doing what they’re doing. You see them deal with everyday problems and they seem human rather than just a legend. You even feel sorry when they are killed at the end.

Another example is the movie Catch Me If You Can. In the movie, Leonardo DiCaprio plays a pathological liar and imposter for most of his life. However, it was his father who got him started, teaching him how to lie and cheat his way out of sticky situations ever since he was a little boy. He also has had a rough childhood, making growing up a challenge. Since the audience has seen him the whole time, through the ups and the downs, we feel a lot of sympathy towards him and are always able to find something likeable in him. (I definitely recommend this movie to anyone who hasn’t seen it!)

I find this also to be the case with Oswald. When someone hears the name Lee Harvey Oswald, they automatically think of JFK's assassin; he must be a terrible person. But after having read this novel, we have the ability to shed new light on his story. Going into the story, I fully expected to come out hating Oswald even more than I had previously, but in fact, it was quite the opposite. I came out of it feeling extremely sorry for him, especially during the burial scene. I feel like Libra was the perfect title for this book, because the sun-sign Libra can mean indecisive and I definitely think that that is how Lee was. Not only was he indecisive, he was also very much trapped in the middle. I feel like he dug himself into a hole that he couldn’t get out of, and by associating himself with people such as Banister, Mackey, and Everett, he was just setting himself up for a downfall. In the end, I feel like it was just stupidity that got him into that situation and if he had had the power to say no and walk away, he wouldn’t have ended up such a hated person. 

Thursday, May 10, 2012

The Untold Story

Everyone knows the story of President Kennedy’s assassination or has seen the Zapruder film, but very few people know what was going on around the President at that moment and how life-changing it really was for certain people

Clint Hill was the secret service agent on duty the day Kennedy was shot and his job that day, primarily, was protecting the First Lady, Jacqueline Kennedy. This is all coming out now, about 50 years later, because Hill decided to break his vow of silence in his new book Mrs. Kennedy and Me, which was just published last month, as well as in interviews about the book. Up until the day that Jacqui Kennedy died, she and Hill remained close and had a great friendship. Hill has many regrets about that day and it is clear from his quotes that it is still extremely hard for him to talk about it, understandably.

“When I got to the presidential vehicle, just as I approached it, a third shot rang out, hitting the President in the head, just about the right ear and left a hole about the size of my palm…There were blood and brains spewed about over myself and the car…I helped Mrs. Kennedy get in the back seat and the President fell into her lap…I was quite sure it was a fatal wound. Mrs. Kennedy was in shock. She was doing the best she could, she was covered in blood.”

“If he [the shooter] had acted five tenths of a second faster, or maybe a second faster, I wouldn’t be here today…That would be fine with me…I have a great deal of guilt about that. Had I turned in a different direction, I’d have made it. It’s my fault.”

In my last blog, I wrote about different people’s perspectives on how Kennedy’s assassination affected their lives, but this seems so far beyond what anyone else could have felt. 

Clint Hill (now 70 years old)                    The cover of Hill's new book

Hill is the figure on the left, helping the First Lady back into the car moments after the assassination

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Perspectives on the Assassination


For my generation, people later on may ask, “Where were you when the planes hit the World Trade Center?” But for the earlier generations, people are almost always asked, “Where were you when John F. Kennedy was shot?” I thought it would be cool to ask the question myself and I got some pretty interesting responses…

Mrs. Harris:
“I was at 6th grade recess. I remember the teacher on duty walking around with a transistor radio held up to his ear. His face had this intense look on it. I don't remember exactly how we were told what happened, but all the adults were stone cold serious and I'm sure some were crying. It's all anyone talked about.” 

“I don't really remember specific events or a sequence of exact happenings. But I do remember feelings. Everyone was in shock. It was a real loss of innocence - for a whole society, really. Nothing of that magnitude had ever happened before. It was terribly surreal. As a kid, it affected my sense of security. I felt like I couldn't take anything for granted - it was like the world shifted.”

Mr. Butler:
“I was leaving math class in 7th grade and there was some buzz in the hallway. At first I thought they were saying ‘Kenny was shot’” [confusing Kennedy with someone else] “but then it became clear that it was Kennedy who had been shot.”

“There was raw TV footage that looked like you were watching it right as it happened.”

My Mom:
“I was in third grade. We all used to go home for the lunch hour, and I had gotten back to school and was getting ready to line up on the playground, when a boy said “Kennedy was shot.” Once we got to class, we just sat there in silence. The teacher was very upset. My house was just across the street from the school, and he left us to go to my house to watch the news on TV with my mother. I can’t remember who took charge of our class at that point. Our teacher came back and was probably the one who told us Kennedy had died. He was distressed, and I remember him saying “This may mean a war” which was not the most comforting thing to hear at that point. I can only assume he was thinking that the Russians had killed him. I’m sure we didn’t do much of anything for the rest of the school day. They may have actually sent us home early. Later in the evening at home, one of the stations just showed a picture of Kennedy and played somber music. My sister and I just looked at it, and I’m sure we cried. There was no school the following Monday, and we watched every minute of the funeral coverage.”

Because the Kennedy assassination is so notorious, I can’t begin to imagine being there at the time when it actually happened, but I thought it was really interesting to hear these different perspectives on the matter.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

Libra: first impressions...and a little bit more


I am very excited to dig deeper into Don Delillo’s world of Lee Harvey Oswald, or as we know him now, Lee. I think that there is a lot to be said for someone who can take a tragedy as notorious as Kennedy’s assassination and turn it into a world-wide best seller, not only because it is a fairly unpleasant topic, but it’s also a pretty sensitive topic for some people. During the class discussion yesterday, Maia mentioned this; when elderly people are interviewed, they are usually asked where they were or what they were doing when President Kennedy was shot. I think it was especially touchy because Kennedy was such a beloved president to many people. 

Contrasting how people our age think of the Kennedy assassination and how it is seen by the elderly population would be really interesting. My mom has told me the story of how when she was little, at school they had all of the children go outside and watch Kennedy drive by and wave at him. This was when he was campaigning for President. She was pretty young when he was killed, but she still remembers hearing the news and all of the stories and coverage. People that are in high school and probably even college aren’t nearly as aware and most of what we know comes from stories passed on from family members or history books.  It would be intriguing to talk to someone who has lived through it and could say a lot about what they know and how it affected their life. 

John Kennedy’s murderer has always been a historical figure full of mystery, so reading this book is very exciting. Because of Don Delillo’s interest in the topic, we get to enter to the mind of Lee Harvey Oswald…or at least Delillo’s creation of the mind of Lee Harvey Oswald. When people are first reading Libra, this is probably the last thing that they think of, but Don Delillo is basically re-creating Oswald’s whole life. True, he is getting most of the story from factual information, but it wouldn’t be called historical fiction if part of the story wasn’t made up. This makes me wonder, would this cause any problems for Delillo? The fact that he is placing thoughts into the mind of one of history’s most notorious killers? As excited as I am to continue reading this book, I can’t help but think of some of the problems this could have caused for Delillo, such as being sued by someone or being challenged by an opposing opinion. I think that writing this novel was a risk well worth taking, because it a fascinating take on JFK’s brutal end and also gives the readers some idea of what was going on inside Lee Harvey Oswald’s head before taking part in this atrocious crime.

Traveling through Time

It’s interesting that several of the historical novels we’ve read this semester include some sort of travel to different time periods or places.  Mumbo Jumbo had one character who lived through different time periods, and both Slaughterhouse-Five and Kindred have a main character who goes back and forth in time and place.  I don’t know if this is very common in historical novels, but it makes sense that the author would want to compare different time periods.  Billy Pilgrim’s travel is different from Dana’s in Kindred. 

Billy travels back and forth between three different places—WWII, the 1960’s in New York and the planet Tralfamadore.  Tralfamadore seems like the future, but it’s just another place and dimension.  Billy’s travel is partly a sign of his strange mental state due to his war experience.  Sometimes it’s his way of coping as when he suddenly travels to the peaceful planet when he’s in the middle of the war.  With these travels Vonnegut also gives readers a different perspective on human beings.  Although Billy survives the war and has a pretty boring later life as an optometrist, his son ends up fighting in another war—Vietnam.  This shows that no one learned anything.  In fact, the war experience seems to be something positive, because it’s the thing that helps his son straighten out his life.  When Billy goes to Tralfamadore, he sees how it’s possible to live in peace and how silly human beings are.  It’s also not clear if Billy is really moving in time, or if it is all in his mind.  In any case, he’s the only one who goes to all these places.

On the other hand, Dana in Kindred really does go back and forth, and someone goes with her.  She travels between modern Pasadena and Maryland before the Civil War.  There seems to be a real reason for Dana to go back to slave times because each time she has to help her ancestor, Rufus.  This is not the result of some mental illness.  Octavia Butler lets us compare the modern, bi-racial couple, Dana and Kevin, to blacks and whites dealing with each other in slave times and especially to another sort of bi-racial couple—Rufus and Alice. We can also appreciate what life was like for the slaves at that time. In contrast to Slaughterhouse-Five, this time travel is not the result of Dana being mentally disturbed.  Also, it actually shows us that humans have made some progress, because Dana’s life is so much better than her ancestors’ lives.  

A historical novel like Ragtime takes place all in one time period, and it looks as if Libra will too.  It would be interesting to know, though, if time traveling plots occur more in historical novels than in novels that are not connected to historical events and people.

Saturday, April 7, 2012

My Own KINdred


My parents have done a lot of research into our family history and my mom's ancestors came to America in the 1600s and 1700s. They first lived in Virgina and North Carolina, so maybe it isn't surprising that some of these people were slave owners. My mom recently showed me documents that mention slaves. For instance there is a will of my sixth great-grandfather, from 1813, which leaves his wife such things as beds, chairs, bushels of corn, and "forty dollars in cash and Arthur my Negro fellow". It is very shocking to see something like this in writing, especially when vaguely in relation to my family.

Another document from a distant relative in 1810 talks about selling Negro slaves. It describes them as "Dolly about twenty six or seven years of age, Thomas eight or nine, Jeff about six, and James about four, and John near two years of age..." The Civil War was about fifty years after this, so all of these boys could possibly have been emancipated. 

It's so disturbing to find people sounding normal when talking about ordinary things like pots and furniture, but then suddenly mention a man, woman, or child as one of their possessions. I hate to find this in my own family history, but probably many people whose ancestors came at that time would find the same thing. When people research their ancestry, they are usually hoping to find that they are related to a king or queen or maybe the hero of a great war, but sometimes they find something much worse and something to be ashamed of.

Family Bonds in Kindred


In Octavia Butler’s novel, family ties keep slaves in one place. The slaves know that if they displease the Weylins in any way, they might retaliate by selling them away from their families. 

This is what happens to Sam, who is sold away from his family for the crime of speaking to Dana. The Weylins also encourage family ties as a way to bind the slaves more closely to the plantation. They don’t trust Nigel until he marries Carrie and begins a family. By settling down, Nigel unites himself with the plantation and his life there. He loves his wife and children and wants to support them, so he is less likely to run away, rebel, or plan subversive actions. Sarah, too, is held hostage by her love for Carrie. Tom Weylin knows he could get a good price for Carrie, but she is more valuable to him on the plantation. Not only does Carrie work hard, but she also inspires Sarah to work hard. As long as she has Carrie to protect, Sarah will stay on the plantation and follow Tom Weylin’s orders.

Alice is bound to the plantation, and to life, solely by her children. Once Rufus tells her he has sold her children, she has no family to hold her, and she promptly escapes by taking her own life. Family ties account, in part, for Dana’s loyalty to Rufus. Although Rufus mistreats her cruelly, Dana cannot help but continue saving his life. She feels a familial bond to him, and moreover, because he is her ancestor, she must save him to safeguard her own life. 

Family connections are one of the few sources of joy in the lives of the slaves Butler depicts. At the same time, though, family ties are what force the slaves to remain on the plantation, which is the source of their torment.

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Ragtime, Mumbo Jumbo...and something in between


Slaughterhouse Five has been my favorite book so far in this class. I was thinking about reading it a couple of years ago, but at the time it seemed very strange.  Now, after reading Mumbo Jumbo, it doesn’t seem strange at all!  It’s interesting that we’ve read three works of historical fiction, and their styles are all so different.  

Ragtime is full of colorful characters, and except for calling some of the characters “Mother”, “Father”, etc., instead of giving them names, the style of the novel seems very traditional.  The places are real, and it takes place in normal time. A character like Coalhouse Walker, Jr. is very realistic, even though he’s fictional. The historical characters, like Henry Ford, behave the way we think they really did, even if they are put into fictional situations and interact with the fictional characters. Ragtime is basically very easy to understand. 

Mumbo Jumbo, of course, has fictional characters, with strange names, that don’t seem very real at all.  Even some of the historical figures in the book seem strange and unreal. Reed adds the mythological characters and has them act in unexpected ways. Then there are strange ideas like the “Jes Grew” virus, which seems like something from science fiction. The structure of the book is very unusual. It sounds different from section to section.  It moves around in time, and so do some of the characters. There are many different styles for the sections of the book, and it includes photos and drawings. Even the font changes, with some parts in italics, some in all caps, etc. It includes poetry.  It has footnotes and a bibliography, even though it’s fiction. The plot is hard to follow, and I think most of us found it very hard to understand.

Slaughterhouse-Five fits somewhere between Ragtime and Mumbo Jumbo. It does have the science fiction aspect of Billy going to the future on another planet, and he travels back and forth between WWII and the 1960’s, but the characters seem like real people (except the Tralfamadoreans), and for the most part they behave in normal human ways.  Maybe one reason Slaughterhouse Five feels less strange than Mumbo Jumbo is because we think Billy isn’t really traveling through time, but his mind is wandering because he is mentally disturbed because of his war experience.  In Mumbo Jumbo some characters supposedly literally traveled through time.  In Mumbo Jumbo, when we go back to ancient Egypt, it is very different from the way we imagine it was, and the main time period it takes place in is strange and different, such as when they talk about the virus approaching different cities.  In Slaughterhouse Five, each time period feels true to that period. 

Overall I think Ragtime had the most emotional impact of the three books, probably because the characters all seemed very realistic, and the story was so full of injustice. Some of Mumbo Jumbo was funny, but it was too strange to make me feel anything, and it was often hard to know what the author was trying to do. Slaughterhouse Five, though, was funny, sad and interesting, and it wasn’t hard to understand what the author was trying to show.  Even though it didn’t affect me as much emotionally as Ragtime, I enjoyed it much more!