It’s interesting that several of the historical novels we’ve read this semester include some sort of travel to different time periods or places. Mumbo Jumbo had one character who lived through different time periods, and both Slaughterhouse-Five and Kindred have a main character who goes back and forth in time and place. I don’t know if this is very common in historical novels, but it makes sense that the author would want to compare different time periods. Billy Pilgrim’s travel is different from Dana’s in Kindred.
Billy travels back and forth between three different places—WWII, the 1960’s in New York and the planet Tralfamadore. Tralfamadore seems like the future, but it’s just another place and dimension. Billy’s travel is partly a sign of his strange mental state due to his war experience. Sometimes it’s his way of coping as when he suddenly travels to the peaceful planet when he’s in the middle of the war. With these travels Vonnegut also gives readers a different perspective on human beings. Although Billy survives the war and has a pretty boring later life as an optometrist, his son ends up fighting in another war—Vietnam. This shows that no one learned anything. In fact, the war experience seems to be something positive, because it’s the thing that helps his son straighten out his life. When Billy goes to Tralfamadore, he sees how it’s possible to live in peace and how silly human beings are. It’s also not clear if Billy is really moving in time, or if it is all in his mind. In any case, he’s the only one who goes to all these places.
On the other hand, Dana in Kindred really does go back and forth, and someone goes with her. She travels between modern Pasadena and Maryland before the Civil War. There seems to be a real reason for Dana to go back to slave times because each time she has to help her ancestor, Rufus. This is not the result of some mental illness. Octavia Butler lets us compare the modern, bi-racial couple, Dana and Kevin, to blacks and whites dealing with each other in slave times and especially to another sort of bi-racial couple—Rufus and Alice. We can also appreciate what life was like for the slaves at that time. In contrast to Slaughterhouse-Five, this time travel is not the result of Dana being mentally disturbed. Also, it actually shows us that humans have made some progress, because Dana’s life is so much better than her ancestors’ lives.
A historical novel like Ragtime takes place all in one time period, and it looks as if Libra will too. It would be interesting to know, though, if time traveling plots occur more in historical novels than in novels that are not connected to historical events and people.
I've suggested a few times in class that, in a sense, ALL historical fiction offers the imaginative possibility of time travel--a reader's enjoyment of the fiction is a form of being "transported" to another time and place, to imagine oneself occupying dramatically different historical circumstances (which, as Doctorow and others remind us, will always entail, on some level, a reflection on our present). I suppose travel to the *future* in some science fiction would move away from the historical-fiction context, but otherwise, I'd venture to say that ANY novel where someone travels to the past would be a "historical" novel.
ReplyDeleteBut traditional historical fiction doesn't usually involve such an obviously "fictional" device. The novel merely begins in the past, and that is our setting. Some of these postmodern authors like to point out the implicit relation between past and present more explicitly.