Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Mumbo Jumbo...and all that Jazz


In Keren Omry’s article titled “Literary Free Jazz? ‘Mumbo Jumbo’ and ‘Paradise’: Language and Meaning”, many different aspects of Mumbo Jumbo are discussed. In my opinion, some of her ideas are stretched a little too far to be believable, but she fights a good argument.

One of the first that Omry mentions is how Reed uses a “musical sensibility” in his writing, which makes his writing less formulaic and linear. Instead he writes in a sort of free-form style. Omry often refers to the idea of a jazz aesthetic, which is basically the telling of African American history while incorporating jazz into it to make it more relatable and interesting. One quote from the article enhances Omry’s idea: “Reed uses a jazz aesthetic as a way of reconciling the violent past with the new demands of the present, ultimately envisioning a future that rewrites racial and ethnic ideologies.” It seems like Omry is saying that Reed is trying to equate African American history with the history of jazz culture. While the African American culture has always had to fight to find its way into American culture, and same goes for jazz finding its way into the culture of American music. The African American culture has long been marginalized by the white community and same goes for jazz in the music community.

Omry mentions several times how she finds Reed’s writing and novel structure similar to the structure of a piece of jazz music, with its many different parts relating loosely to one another. Narrative and musical modes are terms that also pop up pretty frequently throughout the novel. Some examples of different narrative modes include third person narrative, comments in italics, and images can be compared to different parts of a modal jazz piece where the scales continuously shift. Omry says that “by including all forms of reality and textuality, Reed stresses the impossibility of single meanings” and by this she means that because Reed realizes that this is such a complex and “interesting” novel, he has to be open to other views and interpretations.

The title, according to Omry, has two definitions: 1) “an idol sometimes worshipped in Western Africa” and 2) “unintelligible and meaningless language,” the latter being the most significant because the book is about a search for meaning. Omry believes that the title describes the communication of the first slaves to America. They couldn’t speak the same language as their white owners and, if they were from different tribes in Africa, they couldn’t speak to each other. They had to create a new language “one that moved them out of the past of Africa…while still preserving the heritage of this past.” Omry also suggests that Reed is doing the same thing with his use of language in the novel. I consider this to be a pretty big stretch, but when shown like this, it can make sense.

Mumbo Jumbo is definitely the most challenging book that I have ever had to read and at first I was far from excited to continue reading, but this presentation along with many in-class discussions helped me realize how much a style of writing as unusual as this can transform the world of reading.

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Ragtime--The Musical


Last week, Maia played a few songs from the musical “Ragtime” for us. Because I had heard the musical before, I was pretty familiar with them, but now, having read the novel, the music gave me a completely different outlook on the story.

In the song “Your Daddy’s Son,” sung by Sarah, although she is singing to the baby, it is a way for her to inform the audience a little bit about what happened between her and Coalhouse before we meet either of them. In the song, she says “Daddy never knew, that you were on your way. He had other ladies, other tunes to play. When he up and left me, I just up and run…” This line implies that because Coalhouse didn’t know about the baby, he might have thought that there was no future for their relationship and therefore no need for him to stay. So when he left to go play piano, she did the same. In the novel, we don’t get any such story, so we are left guessing as to what could have possibly caused Sarah to bury her baby.

Almost the entire cast of the musical is involved in seeing “’Till We Reach That Day.” It is right after Coalhouse finds out that Sarah died. There isn’t a lot in this song that we don’t find out in the novel, but it gives a completely different perspective hearing everyone come together and sing about it. The main characters and then the different groups all get a chance to sing a stanza or two, so it is really interesting to hear the accents of Tateh and the rest of the immigrants singing in honor of Sarah. The wonderful part of this song is how Sarah’s death brings everyone together, at least for that moment. They all come together to mourn and tell how they will deal with the issues at hand until things get better, until they reach that day. 

Sometimes, it may seem like I am saying that E.L. Doctorow left things out of his novel that musical filled in for him, but this is not what I am intending. I just think it really interesting how listening to ”Your Daddy’s Son” and “’Till We Reach That Day” gives a completely different sense of some of the emotions going through the characters, and I thought seeing them come together in the latter was especially cool. The final lyrics of the song are very touching because everyone sings them together, as one voice. 

Give the people
A day of peace
A day of pride
A day of justice
We have been denied
Let the new day dawn
Oh, Lord, I pray...
We'll never get to heaven
Till we reach that day

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Non-Fiction Historical Fiction

Over the weekend, I went to see “The Iron Lady”, the movie about Margaret Thatcher, the first and only (so far) female Prime Minister of England. Because of earlier class discussion, I went into the movie thinking about the historical fiction factor and how that might work its way into the movie, since it is a primarily a true story. After today’s class discussion, I really started paying attention to things throughout the movie that might have made it historical fiction.

The discussion in class on Monday brought back memories that strongly related to some of the historical fiction in Ragtime. At the beginning of the movie, it seems like Margaret and her husband, Denis, still live together happily, but it is later that the view finds out that Denis died several years ago and all that we have been seeing are Margaret’s hallucinations. I thought that this was very historical fiction-esque, because it was only through her hallucinations (as well as a few flashbacks) that we learned anything about Denis. We don’t know what is running through her head today or what was during the days right after he died, but by working her hallucinations into the movie, it was a clever and fairly realistic way of working his story in. 

One scene, that the director called an “intentional error,” was the death scene of one of Margaret’s good friends. Airey Neave was Margaret’s advisor on Ireland, since England was having a lot of problems with Northern Ireland especially and the increasing amounts of IRA bombings. At one point during the movie, Airey says goodbye to Margaret and drives out of the parking garage, but moments later is the sound of an explosion. Margaret runs outside to see that the IRA dropped a bomb on Aiery’s car, killing him. In actuality, Margaret was nowhere near him when this happened. However, it made for good suspense in the movie and it also showed how emotionally close they were when we saw her reaction to his death. 

Even though some people might find it rude to take a historical figure and, instead of using their words and causes just put them in a certain time period and use them for your purposes, that often helps to create a great story. In Ragtime, E.L. Doctorow made Harry Houdini a fairly big part of the novel, but he did include a lot about his career and some about his family life. In “The Iron Lady,” all of the clips that they included of her husband, Denis, were flashbacks and, what we learn later to be, hallucinations. They didn’t do this to be disrespectful to him, but rather to try and be factually correct when making it as similar to today’s scenario as possible while still giving the audience information about what kind of person Denis was. 

These two examples from the movie worked well and overall helped convey more emotion. Overall, I think that in some cases, the use of historical fiction can work really well, and in others it either simply doesn’t work well or it can be seen as insulting.