Slaughterhouse Five has been my favorite book so far in this class. I was thinking about reading it a couple of years ago, but at the time it seemed very strange. Now, after reading Mumbo Jumbo, it doesn’t seem strange at all! It’s interesting that we’ve read three works of historical fiction, and their styles are all so different.
Ragtime is full of colorful characters, and except for calling some of the characters “Mother”, “Father”, etc., instead of giving them names, the style of the novel seems very traditional. The places are real, and it takes place in normal time. A character like Coalhouse Walker, Jr. is very realistic, even though he’s fictional. The historical characters, like Henry Ford, behave the way we think they really did, even if they are put into fictional situations and interact with the fictional characters. Ragtime is basically very easy to understand.
Mumbo Jumbo, of course, has fictional characters, with strange names, that don’t seem very real at all. Even some of the historical figures in the book seem strange and unreal. Reed adds the mythological characters and has them act in unexpected ways. Then there are strange ideas like the “Jes Grew” virus, which seems like something from science fiction. The structure of the book is very unusual. It sounds different from section to section. It moves around in time, and so do some of the characters. There are many different styles for the sections of the book, and it includes photos and drawings. Even the font changes, with some parts in italics, some in all caps, etc. It includes poetry. It has footnotes and a bibliography, even though it’s fiction. The plot is hard to follow, and I think most of us found it very hard to understand.
Slaughterhouse-Five fits somewhere between Ragtime and Mumbo Jumbo. It does have the science fiction aspect of Billy going to the future on another planet, and he travels back and forth between WWII and the 1960’s, but the characters seem like real people (except the Tralfamadoreans), and for the most part they behave in normal human ways. Maybe one reason Slaughterhouse Five feels less strange than Mumbo Jumbo is because we think Billy isn’t really traveling through time, but his mind is wandering because he is mentally disturbed because of his war experience. In Mumbo Jumbo some characters supposedly literally traveled through time. In Mumbo Jumbo, when we go back to ancient Egypt, it is very different from the way we imagine it was, and the main time period it takes place in is strange and different, such as when they talk about the virus approaching different cities. In Slaughterhouse Five, each time period feels true to that period.
Overall I think Ragtime had the most emotional impact of the three books, probably because the characters all seemed very realistic, and the story was so full of injustice. Some of Mumbo Jumbo was funny, but it was too strange to make me feel anything, and it was often hard to know what the author was trying to do. Slaughterhouse Five, though, was funny, sad and interesting, and it wasn’t hard to understand what the author was trying to show. Even though it didn’t affect me as much emotionally as Ragtime, I enjoyed it much more!