Monday, January 23, 2012

Comparisons to Ragtime


Before I started reading Ragtime, I had had a pretty positive view of the Ragtime Era, from other books, movies, etc. However, since I ventured into this novel, my opinions about it have changed a lot.

One of the first visual interactions I had with that time period was watching “Meet Me in St. Louis” which takes place is 1903, towards the end of the Ragtime era. But the entire movie is just gives an image of how great the time was. The movie shows an ordinary family during this time and their struggles with each other and with society. While you’re watching the movie and getting into the story, these problems seem hard, but not once you put them in perspective.

Another story that is relevant to this time is Pollyanna, written by Eleanor H. Porter in 1913. It’s the story of a young girl whose parents have both died and she goes to live with her wealthy aunt, and just how they grow close and the adventures she goes on. There is a dramatic climax towards the end where she is injured and it ends with them traveling to the city for her to have a surgical operation, which once again, is terrible, but not in comparison.

In comparison to Ragtime, these both seem like stories with such an innocent tone and an unrealistic sense of the time period. Going into this novel, I was assuming it would be similar to the afore mentioned stories. However it gave a completely different image of the time: from the terror and violence due to racial segregation to the complicated love story of Colehouse and Sarah, the story was very different. I think that this is mostly due to the different point of view. The other two stories were from families higher up in the social class and a big part of Ragtime comes from black people, who in this scenario aren’t necessarily lower class, but they are definitely discriminated against and have an entirely different perspective due to this. 

Reading Ragtime definitely gave me a completely different idea of that time period and makes me wonder what other eras have not been done justice due to their portrayal shown through movies, books, etc.

1 comment:

  1. I think you're touching on one of the important ways that this novel (like most if not all of the novels we'll study this semester) attempts a *revision* of traditional or recieved versions of our national history. The kinds of nostalgic pictures of the Ragtime era you cite are, in a sense, the novelist's presumed background--he's adding some of the voices that are often absent from nostalgic histories ("There were no Negroes. There were no immigrants"). Think of Doctorow's novel as the voice of Emma Goodman scolding Evelyn: "Apparently there were immigrants. There were Negroes." And their stories maybe complicate the picture of peace and prosperity by asking, "Peace and prosperity for whom?"

    ReplyDelete